With the number one overall pick of the draft, the Machine drafted MLL veteran midfielder and Maryland alum Bill McGlone. McGlone joined MLL in 2006 after being drafted by then Baltimore Bayhawks as the 13th Overall Pick. Since 2006, McGlone has played in a total of 69 games for several teams, including Boston, Denver and Chicago. McGlone has tallied 101 goals and 30 assists for a total 136 points in eight seasons. Before joining MLL, McGlone was a three-time All-American for Maryland and was named to All-ACC twice.
The Machine also picked up defenseman Dana Wilber from Drexel University and midfielder Max Van Bourgondien from Cornell University. Wilber, who has played the past two seasons with the Hamilton Nationals, was named an All-American, CAA Defensive Player of the Year and First Team All-CAA twice during his four seasons at Drexel. Van Bourgondien finished his college tenure with a career-high season of 29 goals and 14 assists for 43 points in 2013. The Machine also drafted former Machine players Bobby Eilers, Stefan Schroder and Kevin Mack.
Prior to the draft, the Machine announced the acquisition of MLL All-Star face-off specialist Matt Dolente and 2013 rookie midfielder Kevin Cooper, as well as the 13th overall pick in the 2014 MLL Collegiate Draft, in a trade with the New York Lizards. In return, the Lizards receive Machine defenseman Kyle Hartzell.
The Machine currently has 36 players on its 2014 roster and will add four more players before the start of 2014 Training Camp, which begins in early April.
2014 Ohio Machine Supplemental Draft :
| 1st (1st Overall)
|| Bill McGlone (M) – Maryland
| 2nd (9th Overall)
|| Dana Wilber (D) – Drexel
| 3rd (17th Overall)
|| Ryan Nizolek (D) – Virginia
| 4th (19th Overall)
|| Max Van Bourgondien (M) - Cornell
| 5th (25th Overall)
|| Bobby Eilers (M) – Syracuse*
| 6th (41st Overall)
|| Bobby Dattilo (FO) – Hobart
| 7th (49th Overall)
|| Stefan Schroder (G) – Ohio State*
| 8th (57th Overall)
|| Cody Solaja (D) – Hofstra
| 9th (65th Overall)
|| Connor English (A) – Cornell
| 10th (73rd Overall)
|| Kevin Mack (M) – Ohio State*
| 11th (81st Overall)
|| Kyle Feeney (G) – Bucknell
| 12th (89th Overall)
|| Bobby Tyler (M) – Massachusetts